Dicks ThruLines Review

Occasionally I will get requests to look at Dicks genealogy and DNA. I have been reluctant to do that as Ttopic is quite large. Here is the Dicks DNA Tree that I have on my laptop:

At the top of the branching part of the tree is Christopher Dicks born in 1784 married to Margaret. The branches I have under that Christopher are:

  • Elizabeth 1809
  • Frances 1811
  • Christopher 1812
  • Rachel 1817
  • Robert 1824
  • George 1832

Compare that with this document at Ancestry. It is a transcript of Christopher’s Will:

In that document, he mentions four sons and does not appear to mention any of his daughters. They are:

  • Christopher Dicks Jr
  • William Dicks
  • Henry Dicks
  • Robert Dicks
  • I take this also to be the birth order.

I take this to mean that George Dicks would not be a son of Christopher Dicks.

Just to confuse things, I also have a Henry Dicks DNA Tree:

I am a bit less sure about this tree. I think that this branch did not live in Harbour Buffet. Henry was perhaps a brother of the Christopher Dicks from the previous tree.

My Wife’s Late Aunt Esther

I administer the DNA from my wife’s late Aunt Esther. There are two interesting things about this. One is that she is a great Aunt. The other is that she is a half Aunt, so only related on a portion of my wife’s ancestry. Here is that portion of my wife’s mother’s tree:

So Esther’s grandparents were Henry Upshall and Catherine Dicks. Any connection between my wife’s family and Eshter should be on those two lines. I say should be, but in actuality there was a lot of marriages between cousins back in the day on that Island where Harbour Buffet was. This could confuse the DNA greatly.

Esther’s Clusters

Ancesty does clusters of matches. These clusters are with respect to my wife’s late mother Joan. So as I said, they should be on the Upshall or Dicks Line.

The first group in the top right mostly or all descend from Joan Ellis.

  • Lois is Upshall side
  • Wanda is Upshall
  • Jane is Upshall

That means that there is no obvious Dicks Cluster here.

Esther’s Dicks ThruLines

This may be more helpful. I’ll start with the easier Christopher Dicks Jr:

Here we see 19 matches. I think that it would be a good idea to have a DNA tree just for Christopher Jr. What I notice above is that there is just one match under the Robert Dicks Line. The ThruLines show:

  • Catherine
  • Frank
  • Reuben
  • Robert

My Dicks DNA Tree shows:

  • David
  • John
  • Christopher
  • Catherine

That poses a problem. I believe the green boxes are those who tested at FamilyTreeDNA or the ones who have otherwise information about how they match by DNA other than at Ancestry.

Looking at Esther’s ThruLInes

First, I will look at the descendants of Frand DIcks as there are so many matches there. I will pick Andrea to look at as she has posted an Ancestry Tree. This is the maternal side of Andrea’s tree:

It appears that I already have part of the ThruLine for the match with Andrea:

However, when I check shared matches between Esther and Andrea, I see this:

My wife’s mother only matches Andrea at 25 cM where Esther matches Andrea at 165 cM. Let’s check out Joan’s ThruLines:

Andrea is there.

Back to Esther, I make sure that Esther matches Andrea on Esther’s paternal side:

Actually, it is both sides. That is OK and explains all the matching segments and high overall DNA match.

Andrea’s Genealogy

Seems all I need to do is to be able to connect Andrea’s grandfather to Frank C Dicks. Here is Willis Roy in 1935:

Perhaps I needed to go down a line or more:

 

It appears that there was a mother living in the house and a clergyman. The family but not the mother and clergyman are listed as belonging to a Pentacostal Church. Here is Flat Island:

I believe that Harbour Buffet is closer to Port Royal.

Here is what I have in the main part of my Ancestry Tree for Frank Dicks:

It seems strange that the ThruLine for Andrea has two of the same person in a row:

Also, if this is right, Christopher would have had Frank at the age of 69. Something seems messed up all around.

The Reuben Dicks Line

I will look at this line to see if I can make any more sense out of it. Here are the ThruLines from Elaine who is my mother-in-law’s sister:

Esther has a Dicks ancestor further back on her maternal side, so it gets complicated. That is the side that she is not related to my wife – at least not directly.

I suppose I could look at Danny. I like that she has a Reuben Dicks, so of Reubin Dicks in her line. Here is what Danny has for her maternal side:

Collins is a name that comes up, so I am sure this could confuse things. Danny has Flora being born on Flat Island also. Here are some Ancestry hints in green:

Here is Flora in 1921:

The parents are listed also as being born on Flat Island:

Someone at Ancestry kindly posted Flora’s marriage in Halifax. Here is some information from that record:

Here is the birth and baptismal record of Reubin Junior:

The trail seems to be leading slowly back to Harbour Buffet.

Reubin Dicks Senior

This couple was quite old in 1921:

The transcriber was going for an Ellen Dicks as the wife, but the writing is so messy, I could go with Elizabeth. This also makes me wonder if James was a brother of Reubin. At this point, my Ancestry hints are leading me away from Christopher Dicks as Reubin’s father:

 

 

At this point, I am a bit stuck. I do not think that George Dicks is right. At least according to the Will above, the elder Christopher Dicks did not name a son George.

I like this tree I found at Ancestry:

I can’t really confirm the connection to Reubin’s parents, but it seems to me to be the most likely scenario.

The Dicks DNA Tree

It is time to raise Reuben up the flagpole to see if anyone salutes.

As I mentioned before, I believe my tree up until now was mostly non-Ancestry matches and this was an Ancestry ThruLine match.

Shared Matches with Dannynpaul

Shared matches between Elaine and Dannynpaul sorted by closeness to Dannynpaul are:

  • Edward and Stephanie – her children
  • Esther, my wife’s 1/2 great-Aunt
  • Andrea
  • Julie
  • F.D.
  • George
  • Heather
  • Harold
  • Jim
  • Sarah
  • Peggy
  • Everett

The list goes on and on. These are just matches that show potential common ancestors.

Here is Julie:

Perhaps she came out high on the list as she has a Joyce in her ancestry. Here is where Julie should be on m Dicks DNA Tree:

Here is J.D.:

This makes sense as I do have that this Christopher had a son named Christopher. However, F.D.’s tree is private. By DNA, he seems to fit in well.

Summary and Conclusions

  • After a long time off from looking at Dicks genealogy and DNA, I came back
  • Dicks is somewhat obscure for me as it represents the ancestry of my wife’s 2nd great-grandmother
  • Dicks genealogy is also complicated due to the many descendants and ancestors on the Line.
  • In addition, there was much intermarriage of these families which confuses the reading of the DNA.
  • My previous research was mostly based on looking at the specific chromosomes of DNA.
  • More research is done now with ThruLines at Ancestry which does not look at the specific chromosomes
  • When I first looked at the ThruLines, they did not match up with my previous research. This could be based on different people using different DNA testing companies or other factors.
  • This Blog starts to reconcile the ThruLines with my previous research on the Dicks family.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *