MyHeritage’s Theories of Relativity are a good way to check genealogies. They come with ready made DNA connections and genealogical connections. This lends itself to the DNA Painter Program which I use.
My Wife’s Aunt Virginia
These Theories are sortable by newest, so I will do that for Aunt Virginia (also known as Aunt Suzy). I tend to reject the Theories that don’t go along with my previous research as I tend to think my research has been done pretty well.
One of the first Theories (from newer to older) that I found that has prospects is with Denise:
Denise shows as 5th cousin to Virginia. This is on the LeFevre side. First, I check my tree at ancestry:
Unfortunately, I don’t have siblings listed for Angelique Delisle. I aslo do not have her birth information. I see that Ancestry has Angelique’s Baptismal record:
This tree at Ancestry has other siblings for Angelique:
Joachim is a logical name for the son of Joachim Delisle. I’ll go ahead and add a lot of information from this tree to mine. Next, all I need is a baptismal record for Joachim born 1783. I did not find his baptism as a hint, but his marriage record will do:
This record gives his parents’ names. That tells me that the tree at least from the top connecting Virginia and Denis is accurate. Next, I will add the DNA match to see if it makes sense. Unfortunately, the first match is just below the cutoff of 7.0 cM:
I would like to add the match on Chromosome 5 as it overlaps with other LeFevre DNA:
Denis’ match is from 28 to 46 M and represents:
Here I lower the lime to 6 cM:
Here I added a new color for DeLisle and Matte which is dark green. As Denise overlaps on Chromosome 5, that means that the LeFevre DNA in yellow and orange is actually DeLisle DNA. The fact that there is no overlap on Chromosome 6 indicates that the yellow LeFevre DNA is probably older LeFevre DNA and that there is a crossover between the green and yellow DNA. The darker red DNA on Chromosme 6 may be misattributed or due to intermarriage as I have it attributed to Methot which is not an obvious ancestor of LeFevre.
Here is Virginia’s DNA map with added dark green:
Some of the yellow DNA got overwritten by the darker orange on Chromosome 5 when the DNA is not expanded.
Virginia and Annie
This is the relationship we are looking at:
Here is my Ancestry Tree for my wife’s side:
The J F as Eustache is for Jacques-Francois. I have some children, but not Joseph:
There is only one tree I see at Ancestry under hints which has a Joseph:
According to this, Marie Judith Tremblay had 20 children. Wow.
Here is part of Annie’s Tree:
Here is a record I found at Ancestry:
It would seem logical to look for a marriage for Joseph and Marie, though these are common names. One detail from the above is that Joseph was a Journalier:
Here is his marriage:
For some reason, I don’t see his parents listed. This marriage was in 1834. If he was 25 when he married, that would put his birth at about 1811. Here is a Jude born in 1812:
However, this appeaers to be a burial record.
At this point, I’ll just paint in the DNA match and see if it makes sense.
Most of Annie’s DNA would make sense, though I don’t have a lot painted on the Pouliot side so far:
Again I kept the 6 cM cutoff:
I gave Fortin/Tremblay a periwinkle color. Before I refreshed the settings, Virginia was 36% painted on her maternal side and only 22% painted overall. Annie brought her up to 23% overall and 37% overall.
Suzy and Cecile
These two show as 5th cousins along Suzy’s Pouliot side. A few things seem irregular such as Virginia’s Girard being private and a deleted profile in Cecile’s ancestry. I can see from my tree who the missing person is on Virginia’s tree:
Cecile’s tree suppies some more detail:
I now need to figure out if Gregoire was the sister of Marie Genevieve. Based on this, it appears that there is a generation missing on Cecile’s side of the Theory of Relativity. What I need to do is prove that Elysee and Marie Genevieve were siblings.
More on Marie Genevieve
I need to spruce up my tree for Marie Genevieve. Here is a marriage record from 1804
This would put Marie Genevieve’s birth at around 1784. This appears to be her birth record:
The place and father is right, but the mother’s name is off:
I suppose the Marie part is right as I have the mother as Marie Josephte Tremblay. Here is the location:
I am having trouble tracking this person, so I will stop at this point.
Aunt Virginia and Lucien
The problem with Lucien is that his father shows as being born in 1860. Does that sound reasonable?
My Late Father-in-Law Richard
Richard matches with Annie aslo, so I don’t have to recreate the wheel with this connection. Annie matched on Fortin/Tremblay. This is on Richard’s Pouliot side:
In Richard’s Maternal side key, the Pouliot side is meant to be on the bottom. I don’t see Fortin/Tremblay there, so I can add that. Here are two Chromosomes where Annie shows up:
On Chromosome 1, Annie adds older DNA between Pouiot DNA. On Chromosome 10, Annie overlaps on even older DNA. This actually represents intermarriage as the connection is probably with an older Tremblay Line:
Annie fills in some blanks on Richard’s Chromosomes 12 and 17:
She also brings his maternal side painted percentage up to 45% from 44%:
Sylvain and Richard
Sylvain is #2 on Richard’s most recent Theory of Relativity after Annie:
Here I skipped a few generations at the bottom, but Richard and Sylvain show as 5th cousins. This is also on the Pouliot side. Here, it would be important to show that Alexis and Genevieve Gagne are siblings. Here my tree is a bit skimpy:
Here is a tree at Ancestry that implies that Genevieve died quite young:
At this time, I will attempt a shortcut. Richard has a cousin who shows at MyHeritage named Fred. Fred is also at Ancestry which means that Fred has ThruLines.
Fred is third from the right. Fred has ThruLines with 11 of these Gagne Children. Fred, like my father-in-law, descends from Alexis and has 33 DNA matches on that line. Here are the details for Marie-Genevieve:
Fred shows matches to daughters Olive and Marie-Euphrosine Gagnon. I was looking for Theophile Martel born 1790. Well that shortcut did not work. Time to abort this mission.
Richard and Jean-Francois
Let’s see if I have any better luck with Jean-Francois. First I check to see if I have already mapped or ‘painted’ Jean-Francois to Richard’s chromosomes and I have not. Here is the Theory:
Jean-Francois shows as a 4th cousin once removed to Richard, so a bit closer relationship. Here, I will check to see if Elisee and Judith are siblings. I’m going to use Fred’s ThruLines at Ancestry as a surrogate again:
Here I see that Fred has 16 DNA matches with descendants of Judith. I take that as a good sign. In fact, I have Judith in my Tree already. I’ll say that the proof is good enough to map Jean-Francois.
Here is how Richard and Jean-Francois match by DNA:
I recently added Fortin/Tremblay to Richard’s map, so time to map this new match:
On Chromosome 1, Jean-Francois overlaps with Annie mapped previously.
Above, Jean-Francois fills in some gaps.
Richard and Martin
This would be a Pouliot line that I have not mapped if the genealogy seems correct. I am tempted to again check on Fred’s ThruLines.
Fred has Antoine instead of Charles. That doesn’t mean the MyHeritage connection is wrong. I checked Richard’s two sisters’ ThruLines and no connection there either. Here is a detail from Martin’s tree:
If this is correct and Charly’s mother was born in 1844, then she would have been 62 when giving birth to Charly which doesn’t sound right. With some more work, I could probably make some of these connections, but I won’t right now. There is perhaps a generation missing.
Updating Aunt Lorraine
Here is Aunt Lorraine’s ‘painted’ Chromosome Map as 23% painted overall:
Most of the DNA identified is on Lorraine’s maternal French Canadian side. She is currently 23% painted overall and 38% painted on her maternal side.
Lorraine and Marjorie
This connection goes back to the 1700’s. This connection does not look right. I have a different mother at the top:
If this is right, then there must be a generation missing on Marjorie’s side. I’ll skip this for now. Lorriane also has a Theory with Myriam with the same issue.
Lorraine and Denise
I had painted Denise above with Aunt Suzy. The connection was with DeLisle and Matte:
Denise fills in some gaps on Lorraine’s Chromosomes 6 and 17. This brings Lorraine up to 39% painted maternally and 24% overall.
Lorraine and Paul
These two have a small DNA match. I already have a Michel in my tree, so I’ll say the connection is OK.
I didn’t hadd the smaller match as it was below 7 cM.
Lorraine and Jean-Francois
I mapped Jean-Francois to one of her siblings above, so I’ll map him to her profile also:
Jean-Francois supplies overlapping Pouliot DNA evidence on Chromosomes 3 and 4.
I decided to change this match color to blue for greater contrast:
Lorraine is up to 40% painted on her maternal side now.
Bernadette: 5th Cousin to Lorraine
This would take more work. How would Angelique Delisle be the daughter of a Lalonde?
Lorraine and a Different Martin
When I look up Girard/Tremblay trees, they all show a daughter Emerentienne born 1795. Likewise, Lorraine’s ThruLines show Emerentienne:
Here is where Martin shows up on Lorraine’s DNA Map:
Lorraine and Another Denise
I hope that these repeating names do not cause problems in the future:
I see at least one Ancestry tree with a Jean Francois Louis, so that is hopeful.
Here the DNA points out a problem as Denise is overlapping on LeFevre side and should be on the Pouliot side. That means that it is likely that Lorraine matches Denise on Lorraine’s LeFevre side and not her Pouliot side.
Lorraine and Douglas
I am going further with Lorraine than I went with Suzy or Richard:
We see again the name or Emerentienne. It helps to see unusual names. I’ll just go ahead and map Douglas based on the assumption that the tree is correct.
Douglas brings up another problem on Chromosome 6. By the genealogy, he should be on the Pouliot side, but he overlaps with DeLisle who is on the LeFevre side.
Check Lorraine’s Visual Phasing
I have done some work to figure out which part of Lorraine’s Chromosome 6 is Pouliot and which is LeFevre:
Lorriane is the top. The important part is where Pouliot goes to LeFevre or salmon to blue. If the scale on the bottom matches correctly, that should be at about 136M. So after 136M is LeFevre and before is Pouliot.
This shows Douglas’ match to be up to 135M. So that may actually be the inflection point, more typically called the crossover. That means that if I did my visual phasing correctly, then Douglas is mapped properly as Pouliot. That also means that Denise should be matching on the Pouliot side and has a connection there. I checked Denise’s match on Chromosome 17 and that should be in the region of Pouliot also.
Pouliot starts for Lorraine at 26M and Denise’s match starts at 39M.
Lorraine and Louise
This could go on forever, but I think I’ll end it here:
I see several trees at ancestry with a Marie Ann which I take to be Anne Marie above. She also shows on Lorraine’s ThruLines:
Again with reckless abandon, I will paint this match onto Lorraine’s map:
Here I made a mistake and created a new group. Then I merged it back with the old group and changed the color to purple for contrast. Louise’s matches overlap with Jean-Pierre. It turns out that Louise is related to Jean-Pierre in this way:
Summary and Conclusion
- It seemed I got better at the mapping as I went along
- I tried to skip any sketchy connections or situations where the MyHeritage Theories showed multiple common ancestors
- One conflict was seemingly solved through Visual Phasing
- It could take a while to map all the French Canadian Matches as these three siblings have so many matches