Thanks to my fellow researcher Peter from England. He, with the help of Neil, has unearthed Edward Butler. This was no easy task as this Edward was baptized Adam:
George Butler Born 1826 Wexford, Ireland
Adam must have been a popular name in this family as George was also baptized as Adam:
George is important because he moved from Ireland to Cincinnati. He had two wives and descendants who have taken DNA tests. Those DNA tests have linked George to my wife’s ancestor Edward Butler (different than the Edward above). Here is my tree from Henry Butler showing those on the bottom who match my wife’s Butler family by DNA:
Above, I have added in Edward Butler (baptized Adam) next to George.
The Ireland, St John, Cincinnati, and Boston Connection
- My wife’s ancestor Edward was born in Ireland. He married in St John, New Brunswick. He moved to Cincinnati, then to the Chicago area and then to the Boston area.
- George Butler above was born in Wexford and moved to Cincinnati. However, his daughter Mary Ann who was born in Cincinnati moved to St John where she married Thomas Joseph Murphy. This implies that the family had previous connections with St John.
- The Edward of this Blog was born in Wexford, and died in Boston. However, his funeral notice in the newspaper mentions that the funeral arrangements would be of interest in St John, NB.
Here is Edward’s Boston Globe funeral notice thanks to Peter:
Edward Butler Born 1839 Wexford, Ireland
Perhaps this Edward who was baptized Adam can shed some light on these connections. I’ll start with Edward’s death which Peter already found. Edward was listed as married and a longshoreman. He died of pneumonia at the Boston City Hospital:
I found this 1908 marriage:
This Julia A married a man from Digby Nova Scotia. Her parents were Edward E Butler and Catherine Murray. Julia A was said to be born in Boston, but her husband’s naturalization papers say she was born in Ireland:
I can’t be sure this is the right family. It appears that Julia could have been from Cork:
However, other Ancestry trees seem to think that this is the right person:
I’ll try some City Directories. Here is Newton, Massachusetts in 1893:
This is at 220 California Street where Edward’s funeral was at in 1891. I assume that b means boards. That would mean that this was a boarding house.
Here is the 1891 Newton Directory:
I get the sense that Edward (Adam) lived in Boston, but had the funeral at a boarding house where Edward H Butler lived in Newton.
Who Was Edward H Bulter, Clerk at 220 California Street?
Hopefully this is more than a wild goose chase. In 1895, this Edward H was a canvasser:
Here is a bit of a breakthrough in the 1897 Directory:
Here, Edward H makes the switch from clerk to canvasser to machinist. This is important because my wife’s great-grandfather was Edward Henry Butler, a machinist. In the 1899 Newton Directory, the entry is exactly the same.
By the time of the 1900 Census, Edward H had moved to 26 Crescent Street, Newton:
Here Edward is shown as being born in Massachusetts, where other records have him born in Chicago.
That leads me to an interesting conclusion. My wife’s great-grandfather was living in Newton at least as early as 1891. At that time he was 16 years old, working as a clerk and hosting the funeral of Edward (baptized Adam) Butler who was born in Wexford in 1839. Edward later was a canvasser shortly and then a machinist and moved to 26 crescent street.
[Edit: After further thought, it would make more sense if the Edward H Butler in the Directory and holding the funeral service was the elder Edward H Butler born in Ireland. Subsequent evidence has come to light based on DNA testing that the two may have been brothers. That means that they would have been brothers of the elder George Butler who lived in Cincinnati also.]
In November 1901 Edward H married Lillian Frances Kerivan. However, it seems the marriage got off to a rocky start. Here is a note from the Newton marriage intentions dated 6 November 1901:
This note is in the column titled “married when, where and by whom”. This would usually give the name and address of a priest. Apparently the marriage took place but in Boston, not in Newton where the Intentions were recorded:
Here is the person who married them:
This is also a bit unusual. CL stands for Clergyman. PR stands for priest. That means that this was not a Catholic wedding. Perhaps that is why Edward destroyed the original certificate?
Back To Edward Butler Born 1839 Wexford, Ireland
Other than Edward’s birth and death, not much can be found out about him. Here is a detail from Edward’s death record:
Boston City Hospital was not at 24 Clark Street, so I assume that is where Edward lived prior to his death. According to Google maps, 24 Clark Street is the address of the Society of St James. However, that Society began in 1958. The Society of St James is part of St Stephens Church:
Ancestry has this listing for Edward Butler in the Boston Directory of 1890:
Here is my guess from 1889:
Here is another guess:
The above is from the 1879 St John Directory.
Then, if we want to accept that he was a seaman, we can consider this record:
Summary and Conclusions
- I am fortunate to have Peter working on my genealogy as he has come up with so many leads.
- Peter’s finding of this other Edward Butler has lead to more important clues for my wife’s family.
- Edward son of Henry Butler had his funeral at the boarding house where my wife’s great-grandfather Edward H Butler lived. Edward was the grandson of Michael Butler of Ireland.
- I suspect that Henry and Michael Butler were brothers.
- It was difficult finding clues for Edward, son of Henry other than his birth and death records. However, looking at his information shined some light on details of my wife’s family.
- While working on this Edward, new information has been brought to light by Peter concerning my wife’s immigrant ancestor Edward. I’ll Blog about that soon.